Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Big E's avatar

Idaho’s cloud seeding program has operated with little to NO financial transparency or scientific evidence of efficacy. Clips from IWRB Finance Committee Meeting No. 8-24 show members wanting more money but being unclear about how much more they needed. Just “more” was their answer.

The original S1064 put commonsense reporting transparency into Idaho’s cloud seeding program. Unfortunately, stakeholders have amended a transparency bill into expanded exemptions and more ambiguity. Passing S1064 would allow cloud seeding operators a public relations win by claiming they’ve passed a transparency bill while hiding information and creating more marketing material on safety of cloud seeding rather than the real testing we need.

Amended S1064 is a hijacked bill that should no longer carry the title of transparency. It’s unsupportable by anyone seeking transparency and no expansion of the cloud seeding program. The revised bill requires less timely, less transparent reporting and provides Idaho Power Company (IPC) and cloud seeding operators with even more opportunities to continue experimenting on Idahoans in open air under the guise of "orchard and crop protection."

A better approach – if S1064 cannot be returned to its previous version – is to WITHDRAW IT COMPLETELY and try again next year when public outcry will be louder and we have a more supportive federal government.

Citizens who have been nurturing S1064 (and companion S1065 – which we understand will NOT be heard this session) DO NOT support the amended version. We hope the bill sponsor, won't either. Passing S1064 in the Senate, and then hoping for desirable amendments in the House is risky and could be a fool's errand, a task almost certain to fail.

NOTE: Cloud seeding (along with general weather modification) is being banned elsewhere due to unproven benefits and possible harms to human, plant, and animal health; possible contribution to floods and wildfire; and waste of taxpayer funds.

More: https://tinyurl.com/4k6c5r29

Expand full comment

No posts